Navigating Two Distinct Target Markets for Your SaaS Solution: One Brand or Two?
- Mark Benoit
- Sep 19, 2024
- 5 min read
After a recent sales call, a familiar challenge surfaced: you have two very distinct target markets for your SaaS solution, each with unique needs and perceptions. The product in question is a software solution that streamlines the process of quoting and scoping projects for laser cutters used in sheet metal work. One market is largely unaware of the full potential of their expensive equipment, while the other is highly experienced and actively seeking the best solution at the most competitive price. This blog explores whether you should market to these audiences under a single brand or separate them, and it provides a clear process to help you decide.
Understanding the Two Target Markets
1. Market One: Small-Scale Operators with Underutilized Equipment
The first market consists of businesses that own a single, very expensive laser cutter. They primarily use this equipment for their own clients, and often, it sits idle because they haven't considered taking on additional projects. Why? The time-consuming nature of scoping new work, typically done via spreadsheets, is a barrier. This market doesn’t fully grasp the untapped revenue potential of their equipment.
Challenges:
Lack of awareness about how to maximize their equipment’s ROI.
Time constraints prevent them from exploring new business opportunities.
A perception that scaling operations is too complex or not worth the effort.
Solution Approach:
Educate on Revenue Potential: Create content that highlights the hidden value of their idle equipment and how your software can turn downtime into income.
Simplify the Process: Emphasize how your SaaS solution eliminates the need for cumbersome spreadsheets, making quoting fast and easy.
Case Studies and ROI Calculations: Show real-world examples of similar businesses that increased their profitability using your software.
2. Market Two: Large-Scale Laser Cutting Service Providers
The second market consists of large-scale operators who already know the ins and outs of laser cutting. They serve multiple clients, use multiple laser cutters, and are actively looking for the best SaaS solution to optimize their processes. They’re knowledgeable about the available software options and are primarily driven by performance, cost, and customer service.
Challenges:
They’re bombarded with SaaS options and need a compelling reason to switch.
Price sensitivity is a factor—they want the best solution at the best price.
They seek differentiation in features, support, and long-term value.
Solution Approach:
Differentiate on Key Features: Focus on what makes your software superior—whether it’s speed, integrations, ease of use, or unique features competitors don’t offer.
Emphasize Cost-Effectiveness: Highlight the total cost of ownership and how your SaaS solution offers the best balance of price and functionality.
Leverage Testimonials and Comparisons: Use testimonials from other large-scale operators and direct comparisons to show how your solution stacks up against the competition.
The Marketing Conundrum: One Brand or Two?
Given these distinct market needs, the big question is whether to market to both audiences under a single brand or create separate brands and websites to cater to each. Here’s a step-by-step process to guide your decision:
Step 1: Define Your Core Value Proposition for Each Market
Clearly articulate the primary value your SaaS solution offers to each target market. For small operators, the focus might be on untapped potential and ease of scaling. For large-scale providers, it’s likely about optimizing efficiency and cutting costs.
Action: Draft core value statements for each market and ensure they are distinct yet true to your overall brand promise.
Step 2: Evaluate Overlap and Differences in Messaging
Assess the extent to which your messaging for each market can overlap without causing confusion. If the core benefits you’re highlighting are vastly different, it might indicate a need for separate brands.
Action: Create messaging matrices for each target market and compare them. Identify points of overlap and divergence.
Step 3: Test with Targeted Landing Pages
Before fully committing to separate or unified branding, create targeted landing pages that speak directly to each market. Measure engagement, conversion rates, and feedback to determine if your audiences respond better to tailored messaging.
Action: Set up A/B tests with specific landing pages for each market segment and analyze the results. Use these insights to refine your strategy.
Step 4: Conduct Customer Research and Feedback Loops
Engage directly with both market segments to gather feedback on how they perceive your brand and messaging. This can reveal whether a single brand approach is confusing or if there’s a demand for a more specialized approach.
Action: Use surveys, focus groups, or direct interviews to gather insights. Pay attention to language, preferences, and any signs of brand misalignment.
Step 5: Assess Brand Management Capabilities
Consider the resources required to manage one versus two brands. Separate brands mean more marketing efforts, distinct content strategies, and potentially higher costs. Ensure your business can handle the complexity without diluting brand effectiveness.
Action: Create a resource assessment to evaluate the feasibility of managing multiple brands. Include factors like team capacity, budget, and technology.
Step 6: Analyze Competitor Positioning
Review how your competitors are approaching similar market splits. Are they using one brand or two? Understanding how the market perceives your competitors can offer insights into what might work best for you.
Action: Conduct a competitive analysis and identify branding strategies that align with or diverge from your vision. Use this as a benchmark for your own decision.
Step 7: Implement a Pilot Program
If you’re leaning towards creating separate brands, start with a pilot. Launch a sub-brand or targeted campaign under the main brand to test the waters. Gradually increase the separation based on results and market response.
Action: Develop a phased rollout plan to implement the pilot and monitor key metrics like engagement, conversions, and customer feedback.
Making the Final Decision: One Brand or Two?
Deciding between one brand or two depends on how distinct your markets are, your ability to maintain clear messaging, and your resource capacity. If the benefits of your product resonate similarly across both markets, a single brand with targeted messaging could suffice. However, if the needs and expectations are too divergent, separate brands might better serve your business goals.
Single Brand Example:Companies like HubSpot have managed to address both small businesses and larger clients under one brand by segmenting their website and marketing approaches.
Separate Brand Example: Intuit separates TurboTax and QuickBooks, allowing each brand to speak directly to its target market without crossing lines.
Conclusion
Your decision should be data-driven, based on thorough research, testing, and a clear understanding of your market dynamics. By following the outlined steps, you can confidently decide whether to consolidate your brand or create separate identities to best serve your distinct target markets. Whether you choose one brand or two, aligning your strategy with your audience’s needs will set you on the path to success.
Comments